Standards for Critical Thinking
Clarity
We cannot determine anything meaningful about an unclear statement.
Accuracy
Statements may be clear but not in accordance with reality.
Precision
Statements may be clear and accurate but not precise.
Relevance
Statements may be clear, accurate, and precise but not relevant to the issue.
Depth
Statements may satisfy the above standards but be superficial.
Breadth
Statements may satisfy the above standards but be too narrow.
Significance
Statements should prioritize important information and focus on it.
Fairness
Statements should be justifiable (fair in context) in accord with reason.
Adapted from Paul, Dr. Richard; Elder, Dr. Linda. (2002) Critical Thinking. New Jersey: Financial Times Prentice Hall, p. 97-110